The Natural Productivity Cycle
In your personal life, when attending to business or working on side projects, how often do you spend 8 consecutive hours in front of a computer? It doesn’t make sense because we lose the ability to concentrate effectively within a few hours.
Everyone goes through alternating periods of high and low mental acuity. There are days when I work on personal projects for well over 8 hours, but the time is always divided into multiple sessions. I might spend a few hours coding a design, a few hours writing, and a few hours reading feeds, moderating comments, and responding to email.
I work this way because it aligns with my mental energy cycle. Any more than 3 hours in front of a computer and my eyes start hurting and I become restless. I lose the ability to do my best work. Instead of forcing myself to continue, I switch to an activity that allows my mind to recharge. These breaks maximize productivity by eliminating down periods. It’s counter productive to force work when the mental energy isn’t there.
The Problem with an 8 Hour Work Day
A continuous 8 hour work day is a relic of the past. It makes sense for physical labor and manufacturing work, but with information workers it doesn’t account for the mental energy cycle. The ability of a factory worker to think analytically is irrelevant, he’s either cranking widgets or he isn’t.
In the case of the modern information worker, nearly all tasks involve creative or strategic thinking. The way someone answers an email or interprets a piece of information can differ drastically depending on his or her energy level. Nobody does their best work 5:30 in the afternoon after they’ve been sucking down coffee all day to stay awake.
I can’t speak for all workers, but I’ve observed that productivity levels generally peak twice a day — first thing in the morning and shortly after lunch. The most productive period is the beginning of the day. People are capable of creative tasks like writing and solving complex technical problems. After a couple hours of intense work, energy levels drop and workers downgrade to less demanding tasks like responding to email and tinkering with existing creations. Towards the end of the cycle, the mind is so cluttered and drained that workers resort to “work related activities” that appear productive but don’t contribute to the bottom line. The afternoon cycle is similar but the productivity peak isn’t as high. For different people the peaks and valleys will vary, but overall I’d estimate only 3-4 hours a day could be classified as highly productive.
This number isn’t caused by slacking. You can’t force an information worker to be highly productive when the energy isn’t there. Workers can try their hardest, but the work just won’t have that creative edge. The low ratio of highly productive hours to total hours worked is the result of the continuous 8 hour work day.
When workers reach the low energy part of the cycle, they can’t recharge with a non-work activity. The only option is office purgatory. You can’t be highly productive because you’re mentally fatigued, but you can’t recharge because the 8 hour work day requires the appearance of constant productivity. The result is millions of unproductive workers trapped at their desks when they’d rather be doing something else.
Alternative Work Arrangements
The obvious solution to this problem is planning around the mental energy cycle by breaking the work day into multiple segments. The traditional office setting doesn’t accommodate this because there are few available recharge activities. People can’t do household chores, run errands, or engage in recreational activities without leaving the workplace.
Some companies have tried to make the work environment more accommodating by offering meals, fitness centers, and special areas for relaxation. Although these amenities are certainly an improvement, they’re expensive for employers and only partially satisfy employees.
The solution that makes the most sense is a remote work arrangement because it reduces employer costs and allows employees to adjust their work schedule to their mental energy cycle. When a worker becomes mentally fatigued, they can go off the clock and engage in recharge activities that are personally productive like exercise or relaxation. When energy returns, the worker can start working again at a high level, effectively cutting out the low productivity period of the cycle. Employers don’t pay for unproductive time and employees get to work in a more natural pattern that adjusts to their personal lives.
Why isn’t everyone doing this already? Many workers already are, and as commutes get worse and communications improve, the number will continue to increase. Of course there will always be a need for office workers in businesses (like doctor’s offices and law firms) that require daily customer interaction, but for most companies it really isn’t necessary.
There is also the argument that people need to collaborate in person. This is steadily becoming less essential. Most office communications are already done through email or instant messager. Face to face meetings are certainly necessary, but for the vast majority of lower and mid level employees meetings are the exception and could be conducted via phone/video conference or condensed into one or two days a week.
Another common objection is that employees will abuse remote work arrangements by slacking off. I’m inclined to believe that most adults value their employment enough that this isn’t a problem. In cases where supervision is required, web cams and other technology can used to monitor a worker.
I suspect the real reason remote work arrangements are still the exception is inertia. Companies are used to doing business in the office and are reluctant to change. There is also the presence of office politics. If one person is given a remote arrangement, jealous employees will complain. Doesn’t it make sense to give everyone what they want and save a boat load of cash on office space?
I may only be a kid in his 20′s, but I can tell when something just makes sense. I perceive an increasing number of people are noticing the same phenomena. Forty years from now we’ll be telling our grandchildren about the olden days when everyone’s mommy and daddy went to work in an office.


Pingback: The Problem with the 8-Hour Workday « Veronica’s Lore
Pingback: Telepeeps
Pingback: Stirrdup
Pingback: amandacongdon.com » Today’s 5
Pingback: A Changed Work World for the Stay-at-Home Mom « mommy zabs
Pingback: links for 2007-05-25 | noahcarter.com
Pingback: links for 2007-05-25 « Romulo Lopez Cordero
Pingback: Joff : Musings & Rants » Blog Archive » Why the 9 to 5 Office Worker Will Become a Thing of the Past
Pingback: A 9 to 5 job « JAB
Pingback: links van 24 mei 2007 at Andhi.be
Pingback: Why the 9 to 5 Office Worker Will Become a Thing of the Past — AEN DIRECT — Art Director
Pingback: Why the 9 to 5 Office Worker Will Become a Thing of the Past « Splaf!
Pingback: Why the 9 to 5 Office Worker Will Become a Thing of the Past « News Coctail
Pingback: » Link dose » ADRIFT by Jose Marques
Pingback: On Working Less and More | DarrenBarefoot.com
Pingback: Beyond 9 to 5 » The American Mind
Pingback: Getting Higher Productivity is Breaking the 9 to 5 Paradigm | Rice’s Riffs
Pingback: Getting Higher Productivity is Breaking the 9 to 5 Paradigm | Rice’s Riffs
Pingback: Why the 9 to 5 Office Worker Will Become a Thing of the Past - The Third Place - A portuguese blog, also in english.
Pingback: 10 Reasons to Quit Your Day Job
Pingback: Keith Chiu » Blog Archive » 9 to 5 Office Worker Will Become a Thing of the Past?
Pingback: Cartoons Fans Lounge
Pingback: half day.
Pingback: Why officework will die at Onno Bruins
Pingback: Self Improvement and Law of Attraction Link Love, Volume 16 : Today is that Day
Pingback: Corporate Vigilance
Pingback: NNR #14 at nerd news radio
Pingback: The Carnival of Entrepreneurs #23
Pingback: Why the 9 to 5 Office Worker Will Become a Thing of the Past « Veronica’s Lore
Pingback: Hostgator » Blog Archive » Why the 9 to 5 Office Worker Will Become a Thing of the Past
Pingback: The Telecommuterer » Productivity during a normal workday and Telecommuting as a Solution
Pingback: Ellis Web » Productivity during a normal workday and Telecommuting as a Solution
Pingback: Update Soup: Catchphrase Contest, Pick The Brain, and Death Bunny · Violent Acres
Pingback: 9-to-5 is dead in the information society • Rudd-O.com
Pingback: Career Blogs NDTVjobs.com » Why the 9 to 5 Office Worker Will Become a Thing of the Past
Pingback: 8th Edition of the Carnival of Leadership Growth « The Organic Leadership Blog
Pingback: Best Blogs On Home Business » Blog Archive » Testimonials (Home business) All about having your own gourmet candle home business
Pingback: Two workplace-related blog carnivals at Race in the Workplace - how race and racism influence our working lives
Pingback: Jonahan.com
Pingback: Jonahan.com
Pingback: gabusch dot net » Blog Archive » On keeping creative people happy
Pingback: Near-Mint Heroes » Archive » Near-Mint 100: 100 Things I’ve Enjoyed Part 3
Pingback: That Pound of Cocaine Sounds Mighty Good | Prose Before Hos
Pingback: 9 to 5 A Thing of the Past at Digital Wilderness
Pingback: New Found Treasures - 16th July 2007 at Shine With Grace
Pingback: How to Create a Personal Productivity Scaffold (Blog) - Personal Development for Smart People Forums
Pingback: AYR: Advertise Your Responsibilities - SP King
Pingback: Weekly Links - May 25th
Pingback: Friendship, the 8-Hour Work Day, and Electronic Gnosticism « Postmodern Puritan
Pingback: 9 To 5 No More « Alternative marketing thinking
Pingback: Kolz Blog » Blog Archive » 30 Ways to Transform Your Career
Pingback: Lazy Sunday Link Love
Pingback: FRACAT - Free Resume And Career Toolbox Blog » Job-Seeker / Career-Improvement Quicklinks for September 21, 2007
Pingback: Why the 9 to 5 Office Worker Will Become a Thing of the Past at Hmm Heh
Pingback: Moments of Clarity
Pingback: 20 Reasons Why Corporate Sucks « Makeitbetter’s Weblog
Pingback: Work When You Work | PickTheBrain
Pingback: Articles and links worth checking out - 08 May 2008 | 24 Hours is not enough
Pingback: andrew wallwork » The traditional office a thing of the past…. in most cases
Pingback: 20 Reasons Why Corporate Sucks | Just MakeItBetter
Pingback: Interesting Article on 9-to-5 Extinction « Kate’s UIS MBA Portfolio
Pingback: The Evolution of 9 to 5 « On 5 by Kevin A. Wratten
Pingback: 9 to 5 Job is a False Security! | Personal Development for Success
Pingback: Done With Corporate » Blog Archive » 20 Reasons Why Corporate Life Sucks
Pingback: 5 Ways to Make Working From Home Work For You | PickTheBrain | Motivation and Self Improvement
Pingback: Getting Higher Productivity is Breaking the 9 to 5 Paradigm | Rice's Riffs
Pingback: Today Is That Day | Self Improvement and Law of Attraction Link Love, Volume 16
Pingback: Just Be And You Are - Work Remixed
Pingback: Origins of the Nine-to-Five Grind
Pingback: insomnia
Pingback: LeadSwag’s Four/More: Four or More Reasons You Should Learn to Stop Worrying and Love the Farmville — in Your Office | Lead Swag
Pingback: 9-5? No Thank You. « Little Miss Brittany
Pingback: When 9-5 Just Isn’t Working for your Business | Cyclope-Series Team Blog
Pingback: Why Work Doesn’t Work – 10 Fatal Flaws of the Modern Day Office | Career Overview
Pingback: Openkracht » Roest van de Victoriaanse traditie
Pingback: What if there were no offices? | Radical Inclusion
Pingback: Modern Day Central Business Districts, a Thing of the Past?
Pingback: Successfully Managing Conflict in the Workplace | Going For Broke
Pingback: The 9-to-5 doesn’t always make sense. How I work: Discipline. Differences. Structures. Boundaries. Freedom.
Pingback: The demise of the 9-5: breaking free of the regular work day
Pingback: Future of Work for Gen-Y: Project Management « Gen Y Girl
Pingback: It's 2011: Why Your Freelancer Should Work Offsite | CHD Collective - Cooperative Interactive Design & Consulting Firm. Made in NYC.
Pingback: Work less but work smarter—a timetable for success - AMA Shift
Pingback: Why the 9 to 5 Office Worker Will Become a Thing of the Past « Peel Leadership Centre
Pingback: Increase Productivity by Ditching the 8-Hour Workday - CareerBliss
Pingback: Embrace the Future: Ditch the 8-Hour Workday | The Savvy Intern by YouTern
Pingback: Link dose | Feeding the Robots
Pingback: It’s the FUTURE: Why Your Freelancer Should Work Offsite | CHD Collective