motivation

Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation: Which Do You Need?

Image courtesy of The Huffington Post

You know what it’s like to feel unmotivated. You sit and stare at your to-do list, and nothing on it inspires you at all. It’s just a string of tasks that you wish you didn’t have to do. Simply getting started seems to take an unfathomable amount of effort.

Yet, you don’t always feel that way. You know what motivation feels like, too. You have times when you can’t wait to get started on something – a much-anticipated trip, a big project that you’ve been looking forward to sinking your teeth into, a new course that you’re taking, or a job which is going to be so satisfying when it’s done.

So how can you make sure that you are motivated, whatever the task at hand?

Psychologists distinguish between two forms of motivation, intrinsic and extrinsic. The effects of each might feel the same – excitement, being keen to “get on with it” – but the two types of motivation arise from different places.

Intrinsic Motivation

Intrinsic motivation comes from within. It’s the sort of motivation that you get when you’re doing something you enjoy; when the task itself is its own reward. Think of something you love – perhaps computer games, playing the guitar, cooking, painting … any activity you enjoy. You never procrastinate over it, do you? It seems almost silly to ask that – of course you don’t, if anything, you put off other tasks in order to do the ones you enjoy!

One way to make your to-do list easier is to put as many tasks on it as possible which are things you love. Sometimes they might be hard, or you might feel a little resistance to getting started – but once you’re doing them, you find them fun.

In some cases, that might mean rethinking your career choice or your lifestyle. If your life is made up of a whole string of unexciting or unpleasant tasks, how did you get into that situation? What can you do to change it?

When you’re engaged on something which makes you intrinsically motivated, you’ll find that:

  • It’s fairly easy to maintain your concentration
  • You’re keen to do well because the task deserves your best effort
  • You’d do it whether or not you were paid or rewarded in any way

Intrinsic motivation can be a powerful force – but it can also be subject to your moods; when you’re feeling cheerful and upbeat, you’re more likely to enjoy what you’re working on than when you’re feeling low. And for some tasks, there’s simply no way you’re going to enjoy them. That’s where extrinsic motivation comes in.

Extrinsic Motivation

Extrinsic motivation comes from outside. This is the motivation which gets you to plough on with something you don’t like all that much … because you know there’ll be a reward at the end. Think of a time in your life when you stuck with something in order to reach a particular goal: maybe you studied hard in college not because you loved studying, but because you wanted to get your degree. Or perhaps you worked in a job that bored you because you needed the paycheck. On a day to day level, you probably clean your house because you want it to be a pleasant place to live – not because you really love cleaning.

Sometimes, people think that extrinsic motivation is shallow or false – but it can be a very powerful force. Most difficult things become more bearable when you’ve got something to look forward to at the end.

With extrinsic motivation, you’ll find that:

  • It might be hard to concentrate – you may be tempted to procrastinate
  • You want to do the task to a high enough standard to get the reward or achieve the goal at the end, but you don’t care much about it being perfect or excellent.
  • You’d be much more reluctant to do it if there was no reward

External motivation is easier to manufacture than intrinsic motivation. If you have a string of tasks which need to be done, but which don’t interest or excite you in any way, can you find extrinsic motivation? That might mean:

  • Promising yourself a reward at the end (e.g. a cookie, a new DVD, some “me time” to indulge)
  • Focusing on the goal rather than on the process – the finished result
  • Finding a way for the completed task to give you public acknowledgement or acclaim (easier said than done – taking a qualification would be one way, or joining an organization focused on that particular area)

What works for you? Are most of your activities intrinsically or extrinsically motivated – or is it a bit of both?


Related Articles:

How To Be Happy At Work:Employee Motivation
How To Increase Your Will Power

Don’t Forget to Follow PickTheBrain on Twitter!

  • Mike

    Also see Daniel Pink’s latest book Drive that specifically talks about this topic. I have half of it so far and it the best books I’ve read on the topic of motivation.

  • http://www.uncertainchange.com Tomas Stonkus

    Dear Ali:

    Motivation is a hard to manage and understand. I agree with some of the tips which you offer: do more of what you love and motivating yourself by promising yourself a treat.

    These all work, but the key to motivation is building a habit of it. It means having the mindset and the discipline to get get through the tough parts and understand that it is just part of the process.

    Also, one more thing that I realized that is so important and overlooked is this: rest.

    Sometimes, we just get tired and we need to rest. No matter how much we like doing something, if we don’t rest that love might as well turn in to hate. So taking some time off and resting your brain and body might be the best way to motivate yourself :)

    Best,
    Tomas

    • Cristina

      I totally agree to what you are saying, Tomas. A brain that had a period of good rest is quite motivated. At least, mine functions this way.

      Thanks!

  • http://www.freestylemind.com/ Oscar – freestyle mind

    Interesting. For me it’s more the intrinsic part because if the motivation comes from the inside I can continue to work for hours and still enjoying it.

  • http:///www.positivewayoflife.com Josten

    My motivations is more intrinsic. I tend to get motivated mentally more than anything.

  • http://www.theemotionmachine.com Steven | The Emotion Machine

    Great explanations of these two different kinds of motivators. It is important that we know how to exercise both.

  • http://www.anto-dwiharja.com anto

    Hi Ali and everybody

    If you want to know in details the secret of motivation — why sometimes we are very passionate about something and at that time our energy is at the top level, but sometimes we are very lazy to do something and it’s better for us to go to sleep or eat a lot of food or find a friend and start to complain — then we have to know first how our brain make codes about something. If we WANT to go shopping then the codes generated by our brain will be different if we WANT to go to work on Monday morning. What codes actually generated in our brain?

    I want to share with you about Adam Khoo, a top speaker in Asia, who reveal the secret of mind coding in his book Master your mind design your destiny. He gives many illustration of what picture, sound, feeling generated in our mind for situations we usually have.

    I hope his book can help you to master your mind and of course to keep your motivation at the top level every time you need it. Yes, it is possible.

    Here is the link http://tinyurl.com/ybcd638

    To your success

  • http://www.anto-dwiharja.com anto

    I have written a comment but my comment has not shown up.
    So I have to write again:

    Actually, motivation is about controlling our mind.
    We have to control our mind to be a motivated person at anytime we want. Read more the method here http://tinyurl.com/ybcd638

  • http://www.livingwords.net Douglas Cartwright

    Tomas,

    I appreciate the reminder about internal motivation that is driven by the love of doing it for the sake of it. I also think that looking at your list and trying to put more things that intrinsically motivate you is a good idea. However, I think its a little unrealistic to fill up your to-do list with as many things you like as possible. Life is just not like that and whilst you can change your attitude to things you don’t love, some things you just have to do!

    Thanks

    Doug

  • http://MotivationalSmartAss.com Avish

    Hi Ali,

    Interestingly, I find for myself extrinsic motivation is more effective – but it’s really more “extrinsic punishment!” If I have a deadline or someone else is relying on me, I get motivated and stuff gets done. If I’m just doing it for myself, motivation is harder to come by. Being a solopreneur, this doesn’t always work out so well :-) One of my 2010 goals is to shift to much more intrinsic motivation.

    I do agree with Tomas that the key is to build a habit out of it. That’s my plan for this year…

  • http://www.energysmartindustry.com Aaliyah
  • ofmelancholy
  • http://www.mypromdresses.co.uk/ prom gowns

    This is probably one of the best articles I’ve read in a long time.
    Pretty good post.

  • http://masmartthoughts.info/ Alonzo Stangroom

    Why do the article reminds me of one other similar engineered so I just read somewhere else?

  • http://yahoo jeus r. salinas

    i am able to answer my compre exaam with ease…thnx to u guys!!! more power and i salute u ….

  • Pingback: When Are You Most Creative? Larks and Nightingales | Like a Bump on a Blog

  • Pingback: Motivation – Month 1, Day 5 | Being Good At Being Stupid Doesn't Count

  • Pingback: Creativity and Creativising | the design tree portfolio

  • Mary O.

    This article is well put together, and the topic was well explained. I can close my eyes and write my assignment without problem. Thanks a lot for your efforts, good job!!!

  • Pingback: “The Game”: How Cognitive Science Helps to Unlock some Instructional “Hurdles”